Heads swiveled at Elaine Stritch‘s opening at Cafe Carlyle on Tuesday night when Rosie O’Donnell arrived with Natasha Lyonne on her arm. The crowd expected to get a gander at O’Donnell’s new girlfriend, Tracy Katchtick-Anders. Turns out Rosie and Natasha have been pals since co-starring off-Broadway last year in “Love, Loss, and What I Wore.” They told the play’s author, Nora Ephron, how excited they are to be reclaiming their roles in March.